Carrier, Samsung Fight India’s E-Waste Rules At Court, Government Defends

E-waste regulations spark a courtroom clash as Carrier, Samsung, and others fight soaring recycling costs, while the government upholds its green policy and extended producer responsibility model.

US-based air conditioning major Carrier’s Indian subsidiary has initiated legal action against the Indian government over revised e-waste recycling regulations that significantly raise the costs manufacturers must pay to approved recyclers.

The company is among several known firms, including South Korea’s Samsung and LG, Japan’s Daikin, and India’s Voltas, that have approached the Delhi High Court to seek an overturning of the amended rules.

The revised policy, introduced in 2023 and amended in 2024, sets a minimum price of ₹22 per kg to recycle consumer electronics. Manufacturers claim this figure is up to 15 times higher than previous rates and could triple their overall recycling expenditure.

Carrier, for example, stated in a court filing that the change imposes an unfair and disproportionate financial burden.

- Advertisement -

In court on Tuesday, the Indian government defended its e-waste management strategy, asserting that the new rules are essential for ensuring proper waste disposal.

The Environment Ministry stated that the policy was developed following extensive consultations with stakeholders, including producers, recyclers, and compliance bodies, and remained open to public feedback for 60 days.

The Centre also argued that the petitioners, despite being part of consultations since 2021, failed to raise objections during the notification period and are now pursuing litigation driven solely by commercial interests.

Furthermore, the government added that environmental compensation (EC) would be levied only in cases of non-compliance, following due legal process. EC, it clarified, is not a fine but a recovery mechanism under the “polluter pays” principle.

The companies are seeking to quash Rules 15(9) and 15(10) of the E-Waste Management Rules, which establish a credit-based system to fulfil extended producer responsibility (EPR) obligations.

In a court petition filed on June 3, Carrier contended that recyclers were prepared to continue operations at earlier rates and that government interference in price-setting is neither necessary nor fair.

The company argued the revised structure imposes disproportionate financial strain on producers, while favouring recyclers without clear justification.

Carrier maintains that the regulations amount to an arbitrary imposition and could significantly inflate compliance costs. Its filing notes the company’s longstanding presence in India, dating back to 1936, and highlights a strong financial year with local sales reaching $248 million in 2023–24 — the highest since 2020.

While Carrier and India’s environment ministry have yet to comment on the ongoing litigation, the government has previously defended the rules in court, citing the need to enforce better waste management practices. It maintains that the pricing model is a reasonable policy tool aligned with environmental goals.

The High Court has posted the matter for the next hearing on August 1.

India ranks as the third-largest producer of electronic waste globally, behind China and the United States. However, official estimates show only around 43% of this waste was properly recycled last year.

- Advertisement -
Loading form…
Shubha Mitra
Shubha Mitra
Shubha Mitra is an Assistant Editor at EFY, keenly interested in policies and developments shaping the electronics business.

Industry's Buzz

Protolabs Announces GCC in Hyderabad

0
Protolabs is also investing in technologies aimed at improving manufacturing productivity through digitalisation and automation Protolabs has recently announced its Global Capability Centre (GCC) in...
MV Electrosystems

MV Electrosystems Wins INR 325 Crore IGBT Propulsion Equipment Order

0
What does a major locomotive equipment order mean for India's railway electronics suppliers? MV Electrosystems' latest contract offers an interesting perspective. MV Electrosystems is set...
Electronics manufacturing

DUCO Robots Establishes Thailand Subsidiary

0
The opening of the Thailand subsidiary marks another important step in strengthening its localised operations in the Southeast Asian market, according to DUCO. DUCO Robots,...
Image for representation purpose

Japan Eyes Sri Lanka For Automotive Electronics Manufacturing

0
Japan is considering Sri Lanka as a base for automotive electronics manufacturing. Lanka Harness's export record and spare production capacity could make the country...
Image for representation purpose

Hindustan Power Enters PGE Exploration With Madhya Pradesh

0
Can India secure the raw materials its electronics industry needs? Hindustan Power's latest move into PGE exploration adds to that effort. Hindustan Power has secured...

Learn From Leaders

SK Venkataraghavan, Director, Solutions and Services Group, Lenovo India

“Everybody wants to jump into AI, but many organisations are still not ready from...

0
In an exclusive interaction with EFY's Saba Aafreen, Lenovo's S. K. Venkataraghavan discusses the challenges of moving enterprise AI from pilots to production, with...
Santhosh Kumar, Managing Director at Texas Instruments India

“India Is Becoming A Place To Design Products For The World”- Santhosh Kumar, TI...

0
As Texas Instruments marks 40 years in India, Santhosh Kumar, managing director and president, TI India, speaks about the company’s evolution towards end-to-end product...

The Eye That Spots Defects Before They Happen

0
https://youtu.be/vanxJYT2LIo Most inspection machines tell you a board failed. Delvitech's tells you when it is about to.Every inspection stage in a factory traditionally needs its...
Pravin Patel, Founder and Chairman, Brio Agri, India

“Our goal is not to replace farmers, but to empower them with better tools,...

0
In an exclusive interaction with EFY's Saba Aafreen, Pravin Patel, Founder and Chairman of Brio Agri, discusses building hydroponics and controlled-environment agriculture in India,...

Does India’s Chip Packaging Growth Need Local Materials At Scale?

0
What will it take for specialised semiconductor materials manufacturing to grow in India? Packaging volumes will be a key factor as OSAT facilities move...

Startups

Jaisimha Rao, Founder and CEO, Niqo Robotics

“Our Robots Are Tractor-Mounted, With the Tractor Providing Propulsion, So the System Does Not...

0
A robot may work perfectly in a lab, but taking it to a real farm is a different test altogether. In an exclusive interaction...

RHIA’s PLC Slayer Eliminates Fragmented Architectures In Industrial Automation

0
The startup’s innovation integrates separate controllers, sensors, and motor drivers into a single, flexible industrial automation platform. Does building industrial-grade automation always have to be...

EVE NET Turns Spare Smartphone Capacity Into An AI Cloud

0
What if the phone in your pocket could help run AI? A Mumbai-based startup wants to cut AI computing costs by tapping into millions...

Vimag Labs’ Magnet-Free Motors Set To Redefine EV Efficiency

0
Can software replace rare-earth materials? This Bengaluru startup uses virtual magnets to eliminate traditional permanent magnets, boosting EV motor efficiency up to 95 per...

Pine Labs Q2 FY27 Profit Soars 6.5x

0
Pine labs said that it processes 25 million transactions per day, a 22 per cent increase from the previous year. Fintech company Pine Labs, reported...